A Southwest Research Institute (SwRI)-led research team has discovered evidence of liquid nitrogen rising to the surface of Pluto through cracks in the dwarf planet’s heart-shaped glacier, Sputnik Planitia.

According to the researchers behind the detection, the liquid nitrogen evidence captured by NASA’s New Horizons Spacecraft is the first evidence of any liquid flowing on Pluto. They also suggest that the discovery could help scientists better understand other solar system features such as the geysers on Neptune’s moon Triton.

New Horizons Mission Gave First Hint of Liquid Nitrogen on Pluto

When New Horizons captured images of Pluto’s surface between 2015 and 2016, it gathered extensive imagery of a massive surface feature called Sputnik Planitia. Larger than Texas and Oklahoma combined, the frozen nitrogen lake has long fascinated planetary scientists.

When examining the spacecraft’s photos, researchers spotted thin, dark, linear features separating the city-sized geologic convection cells on Sputnik Planitia’s northernmost portions. Critically, the thinner, separating features were more diffuse than the larger ones. Although some previous studies suggested that Pluto may have a liquid water ocean beneath its frozen outer shell, the surface temperatures would prevent any of that water from flowing on the surface long enough to cause the features.

Some theories proposed a liquid nitrogen explanation for the thinner features, even though the research team behind the discovery said that Pluto’s atmospheric and thermal conditions make liquid rain physically impossible. Still, the team notes, the surface patterns on Pluto’s northern Sputnik Planitia “have been darkened in ways that resemble glacial features on Earth that have been wetted by water rain or the subsurface emergence of liquids to the surface.”

To better understand the data, SwRI Associate Vice President and principal investigator on the New Horizons mission, Dr. Alan Stern, reexamined the data, focusing on similar features on Earth.

Sputnik Planitia Evidence “Very Similar” to Greenland Ice Sheet Features

To start, Dr. Stern and colleagues compared the New Horizons images with Earth imagery collected by NASA’s Landsat 9. The researchers focused on the Greenland Ice Sheet, since similar surface features caused by liquid water separating ice and snow have been previously observed.

When focusing on topography, the team said the two regions appeared “very similar.” This similarity suggested that subsurface liquids in the form of nitrogen were rising to the surface and wetting areas of Sputnik Planitia’s nitrogen ice.

SwRI Principal Scientist Dr. Kelsi Singer, one of the study’s co-authors, said Sputnik Planitia’s surface is “quite young” in geological terms, with most estimates placing it at less than one million years. As a result, the dark, thin surface features must have formed during that short window of time.

“Pluto has many unique terrains seen nowhere else in the solar system, and this area of Sputnik Planitia is one of them,” Dr Singer explained. “Its surface provides a different set of conditions compared to what we are used to on Earth, and exploring that allows us to better understand how materials behave in environments that are difficult to produce on Earth.”

To support the visual evidence of liquid nitrogen on Pluto, Dr. Orkan Umurhan, a senior research scientist at the SETI Institute, oversaw the creation of computer models designed to simulate the dwarf planet’s local environment. According to the study authors, the models “show that nitrogen ice at the base of Pluto’s kilometers-deep Sputnik glacier can melt, forming liquid nitrogen.”

The same models also revealed that buoyancy and pressure from underneath can cause liquid nitrogen to migrate to Pluto’s surface via a series of small conduits that resemble lava or geyser tubes. Although the dwarf planet’s distance from the Sun makes it an extremely frigid environment, the models also suggested that once liquid nitrogen reaches Pluto’s surface, it can maintain liquid form long enough to flow down the nitrogen glacier slopes and cause the features seen in the images.

“Pluto Never Stops Surprising Us”

When discussing the significance of the findings, Dr. Umurhan pointed to the study’s  “tantalizing picture that it promotes,” including potentially motivating a further examination of solid-state nitrogen physics at very low temperatures.

“Specifically, it’s important to examine the physics taking place in solid nitrogen materials under stress and strain, which can cause them to melt,” the study author explained, adding that these processes “have never been studied in real detail in the laboratory.”

The SwRI-led team also noted that over half of Pluto remains unmapped in high resolution, meaning there is still a lot of room for future discoveries. This includes further mapping of the other Kuiper Belt planets “to determine if similar processes are occurring elsewhere in that region of the solar system.”

Finally, the SwRI-led team said the findings could offer some assistance in explaining other events across the solar system, such as the geysers observed by NASA’s Voyager 2 on Neptune’s moon Triton.

“Pluto never stops surprising us, and this new result certainly does that,” Stern concluded. “In addition to suggesting that liquids have recently expressed themselves on Pluto’s surface, it also suggests a new kind of time-variable feature on Pluto.”

The study “Evidence for possible N2 basal flow beneath Pluto’s northern Sputnik Planitia” was published in The Planetary Science Journal.

Christopher Plain is a Science Fiction and Fantasy novelist and has spent the last six years as Associate News Editor and Head Science Writer at The Debrief. Follow and connect with him on X, learn about his books at plainfiction.com, or email him at christopher@thedebrief.org

Antarctica’s first ice sheet may have begun with a geological head start hidden deep beneath the continent. Millions of years before thick ice spread across the Northern Hemisphere, forces inside Earth lifted East Antarctica into a vast region of mountains and plateaus. The higher terrain became cold enough to preserve snow even when the planet [...]

Nearly 170 billion tons of ice melt off the Greenland Ice Sheet every year, but scientists don’t fully understand the process by which this melting occurs. Researchers in the past suggested that liquid water forms at the glacier’s surface, where warm air and sunlight melt the ice. This meltwater travels down through cracks in the glacier and along the bedrock beneath it and flows out to sea. 

However, some scientists view this model as too simple because it assumes water only flows downward and ignores how temperature affects water movement. They argue that an oversimplified melting model is unreliable for predicting how future ice sheets will behave.

One group of researchers tested this by investigating how water movement across Greenland is controlled by lakes beneath the ice sheet, called subglacial lakes. They monitored a newly discovered subglacial lake using high-resolution satellite images taken from 2012 to 2019 and 3D surface maps generated from the images. They focused on ice sheet changes from July 22 to August 1, 2014, during a suspected subglacial lake drainage event. A drainage event is like a water balloon that’s too full, bursting from excess pressure. 

They examined images of the Greenland ice sheet taken from Landsat-8, 3D surface maps from the Polar Geospatial Center, and data from ICESat and ICESat-2 taken in the summer of 2014. Based on these data, the researchers identified a 2-square-kilometer (0.8-square-mile) region of ice rising 10 to 15 meters (about 30 to 50 feet), forming a dome on the ice sheet’s surface. They suggested that this dome formed when a large, meltwater-fed lake developed on the bedrock beneath the ice sheet, pushing the ice upward. 

They also saw that on July 22, 2014, the dome began to collapse. Over the next 10 days, it dropped by 85 meters (about 280 feet), forming a basin. Using the dome’s dimensions, the researchers estimated that 90 million cubic meters, or about 3 billion cubic feet, of water drained from the lake at an average rate of 100 cubic meters, or about 3500 cubic feet, per second over the 10 days. This is roughly equivalent to 36,000 Olympic swimming pools draining at a rate of 1 pool every 25 seconds! 

The researchers also found that during the collapse, 40-meter-high (130-foot) ice blocks were uprooted about 1 kilometer (0.6 mile) downstream from the basin, followed by 6 square kilometers (about 2 square miles) of smooth ice. The researchers hypothesized that these features formed when water burst through the ice, flowed along its surface, and then reentered the ice sheet.

Next, they used data from Landsat 5, Landsat 9, the National Snow and Ice Data Center, and the U.S. Geological Survey to demonstrate that the drainage event also affected the surrounding environment. When the water reentered the ice sheet, it flowed beneath the Harding Glacier downstream. This influx of fast-moving water reduced pressure at the glacier’s base, slowing its movement. Simultaneously, the increased drainage beneath the Harding Glacier caused 500 to 600 meters (about 1,600 to 2,000 feet) of ice to break off its end. 

In response to these changes, the researchers hypothesized that subglacial waters rose to the surface rather than sinking to the bedrock because the ice sheet was frozen to it. To test this, they simulated temperatures at the base of the ice sheet using computer-generated thermal models. They input a range of likely bedrock temperatures and ice thicknesses to simulate possible conditions under the ice sheet. They found that all the simulations predicted the glacier’s base would remain below -5°C (23°F). At such low temperatures, the ice would be frozen to the bedrock before subglacial water could drain out. Since water couldn’t flow under the glacier, it was forced to travel upward. 

The researchers used these findings to develop a new conceptual model of how glacial meltwater moves. First, surface ice melts and flows into a subglacial lake. As meltwater accumulates, pressure builds at the base of the ice sheet, forming a dome on the surface. A drainage event causes the dome to collapse. As water moves downward through the glacier, it is blocked from reaching the base because the ice is frozen to the bedrock. The water then moves upward, bursts through the surface, travels across it, and eventually reenters the glacier before draining to the ocean.

The team concluded that water movement above, through, and below glaciers is interconnected. Destructive upward flow of meltwater, followed by downward flow beneath glaciers, can weaken ice sheet structure and alter downstream glacier dynamics. Their work highlights the need for more scientists to consider the processes driving glacial ice loss.

The post How do ice sheets melt? appeared first on Sciworthy.