KISIA Raises Security Sovereignty Concerns Over Foreign Vendors
South Korea's cybersecurity industry has raised concerns with the presidential National Security Office over the growing presence of foreign security companies in the public and financial sectors.
The industry argues that relying on foreign products for critical security infrastructure could undermine the country's security sovereignty, leaving it exposed to price increases or supply restrictions.
Jinsoo Kim, president of the Korea Information Security Industry Association (KISIA), said at a press conference at IT Venture Tower in Seoul's Songpa district on Sept. 14 that he raised the concerns in a meeting with Song Ki-ho, third deputy director of the presidential National Security Office, on Aug. 25. KISIA is a private association with about 340 security companies as members, 98% of which are Korean companies.
The association asked the National Security Office for government support to help domestic security companies grow. "From a sovereignty perspective, it is extremely important for a country to defend its own security with domestic solutions," Kim said. "We asked the government to serve as a catalyst so that Korean security companies can grow strategically in the domestic market." After hearing the industry's concerns, Song said Korean security companies "need to succeed and we will take the lead in supporting them," according to the association.
The financial and public sectors are key sources of revenue for Korean security companies. Foreign cloud-based products had faced difficulties entering the two markets because of network separation regulations that require internal work networks to be separated from the internet, as well as security compliance reviews by the National Intelligence Service (NIS).
Regulations have been eased as demand for generative artificial intelligence (AI) has grown. The Financial Services Commission in 2024 allowed financial companies to use generative AI and software as a service (SaaS) through a regulatory sandbox. The NIS established the National Network Security Framework (N2SF), which applies different security controls according to information classification levels.
Foreign security companies have also begun supplying products to the public sector. The Bank of Korea adopted equipment from Palo Alto Networks in August last year for a pilot "one-PC" project that integrates internet and work functions into a single PC, and has since introduced additional equipment. The products underwent an NIS security compliance review and are operated alongside Korean products.
The association argues that greater dependence on foreign products could make them difficult to replace. Foreign security companies provide integrated security products covering an enterprise's PCs and servers as well as networks and cloud infrastructure, making it difficult to switch to other products once they have been adopted. "If global products become widely adopted and we eventually lose security sovereignty, there could be risks such as sharply higher maintenance costs or vendors restricting sales of solutions to certain companies," Kim said.
Young-chul Choi, senior vice president of KISIA, said technical standards should first be established to allow domestic and foreign products to be compared on the same basis.
However, giving preferential treatment to Korean products in the public and financial sectors could raise concerns about reverse discrimination against foreign companies. Apart from establishing technical standards, the association did not propose specific measures for supporting domestic security companies.